An August New York Times/Philadelphia Inquirer/Siena University poll showed Josh Shapiro leading Republican challenger Stacy Garrity 55% to 39% in his race for a second term as Pennsylvania governor – an enviable margin in a state President Donald Trump carried in 2024.
Part of that strength rests on a reputation for pragmatism: in July he signed his fourth consecutive bipartisan state budget, which passed with the support of 211 of Pennsylvania’s 252 lawmakers. It’s a position that has made him arguably the most politically formidable Jewish Democrat and one of his party’s leading potential contenders for the presidency in 2028.
As his national profile has grown, so has the prominence of his Jewish identity. Shapiro attended Jewish day school, keeps a kosher home, celebrates Shabbat with his family, and has described his connection to Israel as formative. In his 2026 memoir, Where We Keep the Light, he presents Judaism as central to his public life.
The past two years have tested that identity in extraordinary ways. Shapiro revealed in the memoir that during Kamala Harris’s 2024 vice-presidential vetting process, he was asked whether he had ever been an agent – or “double agent” – of Israel.
The disclosure prompted outrage from prominent Jewish leaders, who said the questioning evoked the historic antisemitic trope of dual loyalty; Shapiro called the question offensive but has been more cautious about assigning motive. People involved in Harris’s vetting process later said other finalists were asked similar questions about ties to foreign governments.
Then, in April 2025, an arsonist attacked the Pennsylvania governor’s residence hours after Shapiro and his family had celebrated a Passover Seder there. They escaped unharmed. The attacker later pleaded guilty to attempted murder, terrorism, and arson and was sentenced to decades in prison.
Authorities examined his anger toward Shapiro over the Israeli-Palestinian conflict; Shapiro resisted speculation about the precise motive.
Rather than retreat from public expressions of his Judaism, Shapiro has moved in the opposite direction. Speaking to thousands of Jewish teenagers at a BBYO gathering this year, he said he was proud of his faith, describing a decision to live that faith “out loud.”
Shapiro's relationship with Israel
His relationship with Israel is similarly visible but not uncomplicated: Shapiro identifies as a Zionist and has vigorously defended Israel’s right to defend itself, while criticizing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and voicing concern for Palestinian civilians.
Those positions have made him a target for parts of the progressive left, even as his defenders argue that he has at times been held to standards not applied to other Democrats.
Whether Shapiro ultimately seeks the White House remains an open question. As the Democratic Party debates its future – and its relationship with Israel – Shapiro increasingly finds himself at the center of both debates.
<< No. 24: Gali Baharav-Miara, Isaac Amit, and Noam Sohlberg